logo Thu, 01 May 2025 19:50:29 GMT

Good Strategy, Bad Strategy


Synopsis


When Richard Rumelt's Good Strategy/Bad Strategy was published in 2011, it immediately struck a chord, calling out as bad strategy the mish-mash of pop culture, motivational slogans and business buzz speak so often and misleadingly masquerading as the real thing. Since then, his original and pragmatic ideas have won fans around the world and continue to help readers to recognise and avoid the elements of bad strategy and adopt good, action-oriented strategies that honestly acknowledge the challenges being faced and offer straightforward approaches to overcoming them. Strategy should not be equated with ambition, leadership, vision or planning; rather, it is coherent action backed by an argument. For Rumelt, the heart of good strategy is insight into the hidden power in any situation, and into an appropriate response - whether launching a new product, fighting a war or putting a man on the moon. Drawing on examples of the good and the bad from across all sectors and all ages, he shows how this insight can be cultivated with a wide variety of tools that lead to better thinking and better strategy, strategy that cuts through the hype and gets results.

Richard P. Rumelt

Summary

Chapter 1: The Essence of Strategy

* Strategy is a plan to achieve a goal, but a good strategy is distinguished by its focus, coherence, and adaptability.
* Example: Apple's strategy of creating a seamless ecosystem of hardware and software, with a focus on user experience.

Chapter 2: The Kernels of Good Strategy

* A good strategy has a clear diagnostic, a guiding policy, and a coherent set of actions.
* Example: United Airlines' "Friendly Skies" strategy, which focused on providing a superior customer experience through increased frequency, on-time performance, and friendly service.

Chapter 3: The Diagnostic: Understand the Situation

* The diagnostic should identify the fundamental problem and why it matters.
* Example: Google's diagnostic during the early 2000s, when it realized the search landscape was fragmented and dominated by portals and directories.

Chapter 4: The Guiding Policy: Set a Clear Direction

* The guiding policy provides a clear direction for action and decision-making.
* Example: Starbucks' "100-yard principle," which guided the company's expansion efforts and ensured that every new store was within 100 yards of an existing one.

Chapter 5: Coherence: Making the Strategy Work

* The actions in a strategy must be coherent and aligned with the diagnostic and guiding policy.
* Example: Walmart's strategy of "everyday low prices," supported by its efficient supply chain and low-cost operations.

Chapter 6: Bad Strategy

* Bad strategies lack focus, coherence, or actionability.
* Example: Blockbuster's failed strategy of competing with Netflix in the video streaming market, despite its lack of focus and a fragmented business model.

Chapter 7: Avoiding Bad Strategy #1: Telling Stories

* Narrative-based strategies are often vague and lack a clear diagnostic or guiding policy.
* Example: The "we're going to be the next Facebook" strategy, which provides no clear direction or plan for achieving such a goal.

Chapter 8: Avoiding Bad Strategy #2: Taking Aim at the Competition

* Competitor-focused strategies can distract from the true diagnostic and limit innovation.
* Example: Microsoft's focus on competing with Apple instead of identifying its own unique value proposition in the cloud computing market.

Chapter 9: Avoiding Bad Strategy #3: Copying the Competition

* Imitation strategies fail to address the specific challenges and opportunities facing a company.
* Example: The numerous startups that attempted to copy Uber's business model without differentiating themselves or addressing the challenges of their local markets.

Chapter 10: Avoiding Bad Strategy #4: Making Arrangements

* Arrangement-based strategies rely on deals, partnerships, or acquisitions to create value, rather than addressing the underlying problems.
* Example: The numerous airline mergers that have failed to address the fundamental challenges of the industry, such as high costs and low customer satisfaction.

Chapter 11: Avoiding Bad Strategy #5: Achieving Complexity

* Complex strategies are often difficult to understand and implement, and may distract from the real issue.
* Example: The Department of Defense's "transformation" initiatives, which introduced layers of bureaucracy and complexity without addressing the underlying challenges facing the military.